World Petroleum Congress 2023 Calgary: Oil Industry Navigates the Energy Transition

Event overview

Calgary's selection as host city for WPC 2023 was both symbolic and practical. Alberta's oil sands contain the world's third-largest proven oil reserves — approximately 170 billion barrels of recoverable bitumen — and the city is home to major Canadian and international producers including Canadian Natural Resources (CNRL), Cenovus, Suncor, and Imperial Oil. Hosting the WPC gave Canada's oil industry a platform to make its case for continued investment in oil sands production during the energy transition.

The World Petroleum Council drew over 10,000 delegates from 65 member countries. The event featured more than 500 technical presentations, 150 exhibitors, and a ministerial-level forum with energy ministers from oil-producing and consuming nations. The theme — "Energy Transition: The Path to Net Zero" — framed the central tension that pervaded every session.

The upstream investment gap debate

The most persistent theme at WPC 2023 was the investment gap. Since the oil price crash of 2014–2016 and the accelerated ESG-driven capital withdrawal post-2020, upstream oil and gas investment has not kept pace with the level required to meet demand under most scenarios — including those consistent with net-zero by 2050.

The IEA's controversial finding that no new oil and gas fields are needed in a 1.5°C scenario was directly challenged by multiple WPC speakers. The counter-argument: existing fields decline at 4–8% per year, meaning even a flat demand trajectory requires continuous new investment just to maintain supply. Without new upstream development, the world faces a supply gap that would push Brent crude prices sharply higher, with direct consequences for fuel prices globally.

• Global upstream oil and gas capex in 2023 was approximately USD 500 billion — still 20–25% below the 2014 peak
• National oil companies (NOCs) have filled much of the investment gap, while international oil companies (IOCs) have focused on returns and shareholder distributions
• The shift in IOC strategy — fewer new barrels, higher returns — benefits current shareholders but creates long-term supply tightness

Canadian oil sands and emissions

Alberta's oil sands were both the setting and a major subject of debate at WPC 2023. The lifting cost of oil sands production is among the highest of any source globally — typically USD 25–45/bbl on a fully loaded basis including upgrading — but the resources are enormous and extraction is highly scalable. The tension at WPC was between Canada's domestic and international commitments:

• Canada's carbon pricing system (the federal carbon price) was CAD 65/tonne CO₂ in 2023, rising to CAD 170/tonne by 2030
• The Oil Sands Pathways to Net Zero initiative — a consortium of Canada's five largest oil sands producers — committed to net-zero emissions from oil sands operations by 2050, subject to regulatory and infrastructure support
• The Trans Mountain Pipeline expansion (TMX), completing during the congress period, would add 590,000 bpd of oil sands export capacity to Asia-Pacific markets, directly increasing oil sands production economics

The environmental critique — that expanding oil sands production is incompatible with global climate goals — was represented at the congress, creating a genuinely adversarial public debate unusual for WPC's normally industry-dominated format.

Carbon capture and storage at scale

CCS — carbon capture and geological storage — featured prominently as the industry's proposed bridge between continued hydrocarbon production and net-zero commitments. Alberta already hosts the world's first large-scale CCS facility attached to oil sands, operated by the Quest project (Shell/CNRL/Chevron), which has captured over 7 million tonnes of CO₂ since 2015.

The Pathways initiative proposed a major trunk pipeline network collecting CO₂ from oil sands facilities across the Athabasca region, transporting it to a deep saline aquifer injection site near Cold Lake. With a projected CAD 24 billion cost, it was described as the largest proposed CCS project in history. Critics at WPC and outside noted:

• CCS at this scale has never been demonstrated — Quest captures ~1.1 Mt/year; the proposed Pathways network targets 10–20 Mt/year
• The cost per tonne of CO₂ avoided remains significantly above current carbon prices in most markets
• CCS does not address the downstream combustion emissions from oil sands fuel when burned — only the upstream process emissions

The CCS debate at WPC 2023 influenced subsequent discussions at COP28 Dubai and CEM15 Rio, where CCS's role in industrial decarbonisation remained contested.

Implications for long-term fuel prices

WPC 2023's debates have direct long-run implications for global fuel prices:

• If oil sands investment accelerates (supported by TMX completion and CCS progress): an additional 0.5–1.0 mb/d of Canadian supply enters global markets by the late 2020s, adding to supply and moderating Brent crude prices at the margin
• If the investment gap persists: declining production in mature basins (North Sea, Russian legacy fields, many OPEC members' mature acreage) creates supply tightness by 2026–2028 even under flat demand forecasts — pushing Brent and, consequently, pump prices higher globally
• If CCS enables continued oil sands operations despite carbon constraints: Canadian supply remains available as a swing source, providing a backstop to Middle Eastern supply dominance and OPEC's spare capacity leverage

The OPEC+ supply management dimension is covered in detail in our OPEC production quota system analysis. For the refinery and distribution chain that converts upstream supply decisions into pump price outcomes, see our distillate and refinery gate price glossary entries.

FAQ